Beware of Impersonation Scams. Dilendorf Law Firm communicates only through @dilendorf.com email addresses. Ransomware attack or data breach? Call +1 (212) 457-9797 immediately.

Recovery Scams: How to Tell a Lawyer From a Second Thief

Recovery Scams: How to Tell a Lawyer From a Second Thief

Three weeks after the platform locked your account, a lawyer calls who knows the amount, the date and the name of the exchange. He has a case number from a federal agency, and he can start as soon as you cover the filing fee. In our practice that call is the second act of the same theft, and this article explains how to prove it before you pay.

Key takeaways

  • Recovery scams are advance-fee fraud. The FBI logged 10,516 complaints and $1.4 billion in losses in 2025, and the group that ran the first scam often runs the second.
  • The FBI’s July 20, 2026 alert describes deepfake videos of senior FBI officials and cloned IC3 websites. The real IC3 never contacts victims and never charges a fee.
  • No private company can issue a seizure order. Exchanges freeze funds only through their own processes or legal process.
  • A New York lawyer’s registration status is a public court record, and holding yourself out as a lawyer without admission is a crime.
  • A real engagement comes on paper: a letter of engagement or signed retainer, a stated fee basis, no nonrefundable retainer, and client money held in a separate bank account.

Second call, same thief

On October 14, 2026 the Brooklyn District Attorney’s Virtual Currency Unit announced it had seized or disrupted 241 web domains and 112 cloud servers. They were behind a crypto investment fraud aimed at Russian speakers. Victims answered a Russian-language Facebook ad, bought crypto on the advice of an “investment advisor”, and were later locked out or told to pay fees and taxes to withdraw.

The seized data showed a second phase: a few weeks after the theft the same operators contacted the victims again and offered to recover what had been stolen. Losses ran to tens of millions of dollars; about $300,000 has been seized so far [1]. That pattern is the rule.

The CFTC’s customer advisory “Fraud in 3 Acts” calls fraud-recovery scams a form of advance-fee fraud, a payment now for a larger payoff later. It notes that the group behind the recovery pitch is often the one that ran the original con [2]. The caller knows your loss to the dollar because he caused it, or bought the file from someone who did.

10,516Recovery scam complaints to the FBI’s IC3 in 2025

$1.4BLosses reported in those complaints, including the earlier losses that prompted the contact

$540.5MOf that total reported by victims aged 60 and over, in 2,529 complaints

241Domains seized or disrupted by the Brooklyn DA on October 14, 2026

Sources: FBI IC3, 2025 Internet Crime Report, p. 54 [3]; Brooklyn District Attorney, October 14, 2026 [1]

The badge is fake too

On July 20, 2026 the FBI updated its warning about criminals impersonating the IC3 itself. Fake profiles posing as FBI staff message victims on Facebook Messenger and Telegram with a link to “update” their complaint.

AI-generated videos of senior FBI leaders urge victims to file on a spoofed IC3 site. The site takes a name, phone, email, scam type and estimated loss, hands out a reference number and promises a follow-up. The follow-up is the scammer [4].

The FBI’s rules are short. IC3 has no social media presence and never contacts anyone directly by phone, email, social media or chat.

It never asks for payment to recover funds and never refers victims to a company that does. Type www.ic3.gov into the address bar yourself and check that it ends in .gov [4].

The law firm version is in the FBI’s August 13, 2025 alert. Fake firms impersonate real attorneys, print documents on genuine letterhead, and claim to be official partners of U.S. and foreign regulators. The FBI states that no law firm is an authorized partner of any U.S. government agency.

They cite agencies that do not exist, such as the “International Financial Trading Commission”. They tell the victim she is on a government list cleared to recover through “legal channels”. They then send her to a “foreign bank” platform that needs a fee before withdrawal [5].

The Federal Trade Commission lists the fee’s aliases: “retainer fee”, “processing fee”, “administrative charge”, “tax” [6]. Retainer is the word to watch, because real lawyers use it too.

The marks of a second thief

What the fake firm does

  • Contacts you first, often before you have reported the loss to anyone
  • Knows the exact amounts and dates of your transfers and the name of the receiving company
  • Wants the fee in cryptocurrency or gift cards, or paid to a third-party “trading company”
  • Puts you in a WhatsApp group with “bank agents” and a “regulator”
  • Will not appear on camera or produce a license [5]
  • Guarantees the result [6]

What a licensed lawyer does

  • Appears in the state court’s public attorney registration record, under a name and address you can check [7]
  • Reviews your facts before quoting odds
  • Puts scope, fee and billing in a letter of engagement or signed retainer [8]
  • Accepts payment to a law firm account by traceable means
  • Holds any money that is yours in a separate client account at a bank [9]
  • Is barred by the rules of conduct from promising a result

Sources: FBI IC3 alert I-081325-PSA [5]; FTC, Refund and Recovery Scams [6]; NYS Unified Court System, registration statuses [7]; 22 NYCRR 1215.1 [8]; NY Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 1.15 [9]

Read the left column as a checklist. One item is enough. A firm that will not show a license has none.

A firm that wants Ether for a court filing fee is not filing anything. The FTC’s test is the simplest: only a scammer insists on cash, gift cards, cryptocurrency, wire or a payment app. No legitimate organization charges to get your money back or guarantees that it will [6].

No order, no seizure

The pitch usually rests on a tool: a tracing dashboard or a “blockchain forensic unit”. The FBI answered in August 2023. Private sector recovery companies cannot issue seizure orders to recover cryptocurrency.

Exchanges freeze accounts only through their own internal processes or in response to legal process. The typical pattern is an initial fee, then silence, or an incomplete tracing report followed by a request for more fees [12].

The Manhattan case against Coin Dispute Network shows what the report is worth. Between July 2022 and June 2023 the site sold tracing and investigative reports for a consultation fee and a recovery fee, both in Ether. Investigators spoke with more than 175 customers; not one recovered any cryptocurrency.

The operator, who used the alias “Max Handler”, is alleged to have kept the fees and extracted additional Ether from at least three customers with fabricated tracing reports. He is charged with grand larceny and scheme to defraud; the charges are allegations [13].

Tracing is an input to a legal process, and the process is what moves money. That means a subpoena, a court order, a law enforcement request, then a judgment, an award, a settlement or a Justice Department remission. If the person on the phone cannot name which of those he will obtain, and from whom, he is selling you a PDF.

A license is a public record

A lawyer’s standing is not a matter of trust. In New York every admitted attorney files a biennial registration under Part 118 of the Rules of the Chief Administrator. The Unified Court System publishes the status: “Currently Registered”, “Delinquent”, “Suspended”, “Disbarred”, “Resigned”.

For disciplinary history or a certificate of good standing you contact the Appellate Division [7]. The criminal law backs the record. Judiciary Law section 478 makes it unlawful for anyone not admitted to practice or appear as an attorney, or to hold himself out as entitled to practice.

It also bars such a person from using the title “lawyer” or “attorney” or advertising a law office [14]. Under section 485-a, falsely holding yourself out as licensed becomes a class E felony once it causes another person monetary loss or damages exceeding $1,000 [15].

Most recovery scammers are abroad and will never see a New York courtroom. The statute matters to you because it makes the license a fact a real lawyer can prove in a minute and a fake one cannot prove at all.

  1. Search the court record yourself. Use the state court system’s attorney search, opened by typing the court’s address, not a link from the email. Match the name, registration number and business address against what you were sent.
  2. Call the firm through its public number. Find the number independently and ask whether the person who contacted you works there.
  3. Insist on a live video meeting and a copy of the license. The FBI’s advice: if these cannot be produced readily, assume the firm is not legitimate [5].
  4. Ask for the engagement letter before any payment. It names the lawyer, the scope, the fee and billing.
  5. Pay a law firm, by traceable means, after the letter is signed. Never crypto, never gift cards, never a third party.

Sources: NYS Unified Court System [7]; FBI IC3 alert I-081325-PSA [5]; FTC [6]

A real engagement is on paper

New York makes the paperwork mandatory. Under 22 NYCRR 1215.1, a lawyer who takes on a client for a fee must provide a written letter of engagement. It is due before the representation begins or within a reasonable time after.

It must state the scope, the fees, expenses and billing practices, and, where applicable, the right to arbitrate a fee dispute under Part 137. A signed retainer agreement covering the same points may be used instead [8].

The rule does not apply where the fee is expected to be under $3,000 [16]. A recovery scammer’s “retainer” is never under $3,000 and never comes with a letter.

The Rules of Professional Conduct add the rest. Rule 1.5(c) requires a contingent fee to be set out in writing, with the percentages and the expenses that come out of the recovery. Rule 1.5(d)(4) prohibits a nonrefundable retainer fee; a reasonable minimum fee clause is allowed only if spelled out in plain language.

Rule 1.15 makes the lawyer a fiduciary over client money, and forbids commingling. It requires the funds to be kept in a separate account at a banking institution within New York State [10] [9]. None of that describes a wallet address on Telegram.

Rule 7.1, rewritten by the Appellate Division effective June 1, 2026, forbids any false or misleading communication about a lawyer’s services [11]. A guarantee of recovery is either a rule violation by a real lawyer or a tell from a fake one. Either way, do not pay for it.

What an honest assessment sounds like

A lawyer who has read your transaction hashes will say something uncomfortable. If the funds landed at a regulated exchange with a U.S. presence, there is a path: a demand, a freeze request, a subpoena, possibly arbitration under the platform’s user agreement.

If they went through a mixer or into an offshore venue beyond legal process, the realistic path is different. It is an IC3 complaint, and a remission petition if the government later forfeits assets.

The Justice Department states that it will never ask for payment to participate in or receive funds from the remission process. It says a fee request from an unknown source is fraud [17]. Law enforcement does not charge victims for investigations either [12].

A retainer paid to a real firm buys work: the analysis, the letters, the filings. It does not buy the outcome, and the engagement letter will say so. If that is not what you want to hear, it is still the only version worth paying for.

Result: a lawyer can be verified in a public record, puts the fee on paper and refuses to guarantee the result; a recovery scammer fails all three tests.

Sources: NYS Unified Court System [7]; 22 NYCRR 1215.1 [8]; NY Rules of Professional Conduct, Rule 7.1 [11]

How Dilendorf Law Firm helps

Dilendorf Law Firm is based in Manhattan’s Financial District. Max Dilendorf has worked in digital assets since 2017. On theft and recovery matters the firm works with retired federal law enforcement agents who give a candid assessment of recovery prospects before anyone spends money chasing them.

We represent individuals and businesses who have lost cryptocurrency to investment fraud, account takeovers and exchange failures, including people who have already paid a “recovery firm”. We review the transactions, identify the exchanges and intermediaries that legal process can touch, and send freeze and preservation demands.

We pursue arbitration or litigation against platforms where the facts support it, and prepare IC3 reports and remission petitions. We will tell you when the realistic answer is no.

Send us:

  • Wallet addresses and transaction hashes for the original transfers
  • A timeline of the loss and of every later contact offering recovery
  • Every document, website address and payment demand the recovery firm sent you
  • Any report you filed with IC3, the police or a regulator

We respond with a written assessment within 48 hours. Paid consultations only.

Frequently asked questions

The caller knew my exact loss. Does that prove he is legitimate?

No, it proves he has your file, and the FBI lists knowledge of the exact amounts and dates of your transfers as a red flag. The data comes from the original scammers or from lists traded among them, and the FTC describes the same lists. A real lawyer learns your facts from you, after you contact the firm.

A real law firm’s name and letterhead appear on the documents. Can I rely on that?

Not without checking. The FBI’s August 2025 alert says fake firms impersonate real attorneys and use genuine letterhead, and that the real lawyers are harmed by it. Look the lawyer up in the state court’s attorney registration record, then call the firm through a number you found yourself and ask whether the person works there.

Is it ever legitimate for a lawyer to ask for money up front?

Yes, lawyers commonly ask for an advance retainer against hourly work. In New York it must come with a letter of engagement or signed retainer agreement once the fee is expected to be $3,000 or more. The retainer cannot be nonrefundable, and the payment goes to the firm by traceable means, never in cryptocurrency or gift cards to a third party.

Can a recovery company get an exchange to freeze or return my funds?

Not on its own authority. The FBI states that private companies cannot issue seizure orders and that exchanges freeze accounts only through internal processes or in response to legal process. A lawyer can send a demand and pursue a subpoena, court order or arbitration, while a company offering a “freeze” for a fee is selling something it cannot deliver.

I already paid a recovery firm. What now?

Stop all contact and do not pay the next fee, whatever it is called, and record every address, account and message. File a complaint at www.ic3.gov that covers both the original loss and the recovery payment, and report to your state attorney general. Then have a licensed lawyer review whether the original funds can still be recovered.

Sources

[1] Brooklyn District Attorney’s Office, Brooklyn DA’s Virtual Currency Unit Dismantles Infrastructure of Multinational Crypto Investment Scam that Targeted Russian Speakers (October 14, 2026). https://www.brooklynda.org/2026/10/14/brooklyn-das-virtual-currency-unit-dismantles-infrastructure-of-multinational-crypto-investment-scam-that-targeted-russian-speakers/

[2] Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Release 8936-24, CFTC Customer Advisory: Fraud in 3 Acts (July 30, 2024). https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8936-24

[3] FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 Internet Crime Report (2026). https://www.ic3.gov/AnnualReport/Reports/2025_IC3Report.pdf

[4] FBI IC3, Alert I-072026-PSA, FBI Warns of Scammers Impersonating the IC3 (July 20, 2026). https://www.ic3.gov/PSA/2026/PSA260720

[5] FBI IC3, Alert I-081325-PSA, Fictitious Law Firms Targeting Cryptocurrency Scam Victims Combine Multiple Exploitation Tactics While Offering to Recover Funds (August 13, 2025). https://www.ic3.gov/PSA/2025/PSA250813

[6] Federal Trade Commission, Refund and Recovery Scams (December 2023). https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/refund-and-recovery-scams

[7] New York State Unified Court System, Description of Registration Statuses for NYS Attorneys. https://iappscontent.courts.state.ny.us/aronline/Attorney-Registration_Status_Descriptions.pdf

[8] 22 NYCRR 1215.1, Requirements (letter of engagement). https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/new-york/22-NYCRR-1215.1

[9] 22 NYCRR 1200.1.15, Rule 1.15, Preserving identity of funds and property of others. https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/new-york/22-NYCRR-1200.1.15

[10] 22 NYCRR 1200.1.5, Rule 1.5, Fees and division of fees. https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/new-york/22-NYCRR-1200.1.5

[11] New York State Supreme Court, Appellate Division, Joint Order dated May 27, 2026 amending Rules 1.0, 7.1, 7.3 and 7.4 of Part 1200, effective June 1, 2026 (22 NYCRR Part 1200 amendments page). https://www.nycourts.gov/rules/amendments-joint-rules-departments-appellate-division

[12] FBI IC3, Alert I-081123-PSA, Increase in Companies Falsely Claiming an Ability to Recover Funds Lost in Cryptocurrency Investment Scams (August 11, 2023). https://www.ic3.gov/PSA/2023/PSA230811

[13] U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, HSI New York task force investigation leads to charges against man who used scam cryptocurrency recovery business (August 5, 2024). https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/hsi-new-york-task-force-investigation-leads-charges-against-man-who-used-scam

[14] New York Judiciary Law § 478, Practicing or appearing as attorney-at-law without being admitted and registered. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/JUD/478

[15] New York Judiciary Law § 485-a, Violation of certain sections a class E felony. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/JUD/485-A

[16] 22 NYCRR 1215.2, Exceptions. https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/new-york/22-NYCRR-1215.2

[17] U.S. Department of Justice, Criminal Division, Money Laundering and Asset Recovery Section, Remission. https://www.justice.gov/criminal/criminal-mlars/remission

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Recovery outcomes depend on the facts of each matter and no result is guaranteed. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Dilendorf Law Firm. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Attorney Advertising.

Discuss Your Matter

Confidential consultations by appointment.

Call us now Request consultation