Beware of Impersonation Scams. Dilendorf Law Firm communicates only through @dilendorf.com email addresses. Ransomware attack or data breach? Call +1 (212) 457-9797 immediately.

Tech Startup Disputes: Formation Mistakes That Cause Deadlock

Tech Startup Disputes: Formation Mistakes That Cause Deadlock

Many AI and technology companies are formed in an afternoon with online templates. The gaps in those documents often stay hidden until the founders disagree.

Key takeaways

  • The state of incorporation determines which law, and often which court, decides a founder dispute.
  • An equal split with a two-person board has no tie-breaker unless the documents create one.
  • Template documents rarely explain how a founder leaves the company.
  • Code, models, data and accounts should belong to the company from the first day.

An illustrative example

Consider two engineers who start an AI company, one living in Brooklyn and the other in Austin.

They incorporate in Delaware because an online formation service offers it as the default. Neither founder lives or works there.

Each founder takes half of the shares and one of two board seats. They sign template bylaws and stock agreements, but no stockholders’ agreement.

The code repository and cloud account are opened under one founder’s personal email.

Two years later, the founders disagree about an acquisition offer. Each votes against the other’s proposals, and the company cannot act.

That is a deadlock. The example is illustrative and does not describe a client matter.

Mistake 1: Choosing Delaware by default

Delaware is a common choice for companies that plan to raise venture capital. The choice should be a decision, not a default.

New York’s highest court has stated that “the substantive law of a company’s place of incorporation presumptively applies to causes of action arising from its internal affairs” [1]. Internal affairs are the relations among the company, its directors, its officers and its stockholders.

Delaware law also allows bylaws to require that internal corporate claims “shall be brought solely and exclusively in any or all of the courts in this State” [2]. Founders should check whether their template bylaws contain that clause.

A New York appellate court has held that New York courts “do not have subject matter jurisdiction to judicially dissolve a foreign business entity”, meaning one formed in another state [3]. That case involved a Delaware limited liability company with two equal owners and its only place of business in New York [3].

Founders who live and work in New York may then have to resolve their most important dispute in a Delaware court.

For a New York corporation, holders of half of the voting shares may petition a New York court for dissolution when the directors are too divided to act [4].

A Delaware corporation must also file an annual report and pay franchise tax in Delaware [5]. If it does business in New York, it needs New York authorization [6].

Mistake 2: An equal split with no tie-breaker

Under Delaware law, the board acts by “the vote of the majority of the directors present at a meeting at which a quorum is present” [7]. A quorum is the minimum number of directors needed to hold a meeting, and the default is a majority of the full board [7].

On a two-person board, one absent director prevents a quorum. One opposing vote prevents a majority.

A director may be removed by the holders of “a majority of the shares then entitled to vote at an election of directors” [7]. A founder with exactly half of the shares does not hold a majority.

Mistake 3: No stockholders’ agreement

Delaware permits stockholders to agree in writing that their shares will be voted “as determined in accordance with a procedure agreed upon by them” [8]. A stockholders’ agreement can name a tie-breaking director and set the terms for one founder to buy out the other.

Without that agreement, the remaining remedies are in court. The Delaware Court of Chancery may appoint a custodian, a court-appointed person who manages the company, when stockholders are “so divided that they have failed to elect successors to directors” [8].

The custodian’s default role is “to continue the business of the corporation and not to liquidate its affairs” [8]. That proceeding takes place in Delaware.

Mistake 4: Vesting terms nobody read

Vesting means a founder earns shares over time. Template stock agreements commonly give the company a right to buy back unvested shares when a founder stops working.

Founders should know what counts as service, how long the company has to act and who decides for the company. On a deadlocked board, nobody may have authority to exercise the right.

A Section 83(b) election lets a founder report restricted stock as income in the year of transfer instead of as the shares vest. The IRS form states that the election must be filed “no later than 30 days after the date the property was transferred” [9].

Mistake 5: Intellectual property and accounts in personal names

An AI company’s value is in its code, model weights, training data and brand. Each founder should assign that work to the company in writing.

In New York, an employee’s assignment clause does not apply to an invention developed “entirely on his or her own time” without the employer’s resources, unless the invention relates to the employer’s business or results from work for the employer [10].

The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) states that an application naming the wrong owner cannot be corrected, and the only option is to “start over with a new application” [11].

Repositories, cloud accounts and API credentials should be opened in the company’s name.

What to decide before you file

  • State of incorporation: choose it with the dispute forum in mind.
  • Tie-breaker: add a third director or a neutral with a deciding vote on defined matters.
  • Buy-sell terms: state who may buy, at what price and by when.
  • Vesting: define service, deadlines and authority to act.
  • Ownership: sign written assignments and use company-owned accounts.
  • Consistency: use the same governing law and forum in every document.

Our article Legal Counsel for AI Startups covers formation documents, founder equity and seed financing. Our pages on founder, partner and shareholder disputes and part-time general counsel describe related services.

How Dilendorf Law Firm helps

Dilendorf Law Firm is a New York law firm. We represent founders, startups and established AI companies.

  • Corporate formation: choice of state, charter, bylaws, stockholders’ agreements, founder stock and intellectual property assignments.
  • Outside general counsel: ongoing corporate, contract and governance work for startups.
  • Corporate disputes: founder separations, deadlock, buyout negotiations, litigation and arbitration.

We prepare initial corporate documents with a possible founder dispute in mind. Contact Dilendorf Law Firm to discuss your company’s situation.

Frequently asked questions

Is Delaware the wrong choice for an AI startup?

Not always. Founders should choose Delaware knowing that Delaware law, and often Delaware courts, will govern their internal disputes.

What happens when two equal founders cannot agree?

Neither founder can act alone unless the documents provide a tie-breaker. In a deadlock, Delaware law allows a stockholder to ask the Court of Chancery to appoint a custodian.

Can a New York court dissolve a Delaware company?

A New York appellate court has held that New York courts lack jurisdiction to dissolve a business entity formed in another state. That request must be made in the state of formation.

Sources

[1] Eccles v. Shamrock Capital Advisors, LLC, 2024 NY Slip Op 02841, New York Court of Appeals (May 23, 2024). https://nycourts.gov/reporter/3dseries/2024/2024_02841.htm

[2] Delaware General Corporation Law, 8 Del. C. § 115, forum selection provisions. https://delcode.delaware.gov/title8/c001/sc01/index.html

[3] Matter of Raharney Capital, LLC v. Capital Stack LLC, 2016 NY Slip Op 01425, Appellate Division, First Department (February 25, 2016). https://www.nycourts.gov/Reporter/3dseries/2016/2016_01425.htm

[4] New York Business Corporation Law § 1104, petition in case of deadlock among directors or shareholders. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/BSC/1104

[5] Delaware Division of Corporations, Annual Report and Tax Information. https://corp.delaware.gov/frtax/

[6] New York Business Corporation Law § 1301, authorization of foreign corporations. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/BSC/1301

[7] Delaware General Corporation Law, 8 Del. C. § 141(b) and (k), board of directors. https://delcode.delaware.gov/title8/c001/sc04/index.html

[8] Delaware General Corporation Law, 8 Del. C. §§ 218(c) and 226, voting agreements and appointment of a custodian. https://delcode.delaware.gov/title8/c001/sc07/index.html

[9] Internal Revenue Service, Form 15620, Section 83(b) Election (April 2025). https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f15620.pdf

[10] New York Labor Law § 203-f, inventions made by employees. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/LAB/203-F

[11] United States Patent and Trademark Office, Common problems in applications. https://www.uspto.gov/trademarks/basics/common-problems

This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Dilendorf Law Firm. Attorney Advertising.

Discuss Your Matter

Confidential consultations by appointment.

Call us now Request consultation