An employee types the company’s banking credentials into a convincing fake login page. Within hours, a string of wires has left the operating account.
The board’s first question is whether the bank must return the money.
Sometimes it must. In our experience, though, these are difficult claims to fight, and a board should understand why before it commits to one.
The rule in brief
Business wire transfers are governed by Article 4-A of the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC), a set of commercial laws that each state adopts. The starting point favors the customer.
A bank that accepts a payment order that is “not authorized and not effective as the order of the customer” must refund it with interest (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-204) [1].
If the bank and customer agreed to verify orders through a security procedure, the order may be effective “whether or not authorized.”
However, the procedure must be “a commercially reasonable method of providing security against unauthorized payment orders.”
The bank must also prove that it “accepted the payment order in good faith and in compliance with the bank’s obligations under the security procedure.” (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-202(2)) [2].
The bank carries that burden, but it helps the customer less than it first appears.
Read the bank’s terms first
The account and treasury agreements shape the dispute in three ways.
Forum. In our experience, these agreements often require arbitration, a private proceeding decided by an arbitrator instead of a judge or jury.
Federal law makes a written arbitration clause in a commercial contract “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable” (9 U.S.C. § 2) [3]. The claim may well begin there, not in court.
What the bank promised. A security procedure is one “established by agreement of a customer and a receiving bank” (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-201) [4].
As one federal appeals court put it, “security measures implemented unilaterally by the bank are irrelevant” (Choice Escrow v. BancorpSouth Bank, 8th Cir. 2014) [5]. The bank’s internal fraud monitoring may not be part of what it agreed to do.
What the company declined. A procedure is deemed reasonable if the customer refused a commercially reasonable option and “expressly agreed in a record to be bound” by orders accepted under the one it chose (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-202(3)) [2].
In Choice Escrow, the customer had declined dual control, which requires a second employee to approve each wire. The court treated it as having “voluntarily assumed the risk of failure of the procedure” and let the bank seek its attorney’s fees under the agreement [5].
When the credentials came from inside
A customer can still recover on an effective order by proving the fraud did not come through its own people or systems. That defense fails if the fraudster obtained access “from a source controlled by the customer,” and the statute adds: “regardless of how the information was obtained or whether the customer was at fault” (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-203) [6].
Being deceived does not rescue that defense. The claim then depends on the bank failing to prove its own case.
Reasonable does not mean best
Commercial reasonableness is “a question of law” that weighs, among other factors, “the size, type, and frequency of payment orders normally issued by the customer” (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-202(3)) [2]. Customers often read that as a duty to stop wires that look out of character.
Courts have not read it that way. The Eighth Circuit held that Article 4-A “does not instruct the bank to consider the ‘size, type, and frequency’ of each payment order it receives in determining if those payment orders are potentially fraudulent; it instructs the court to consider these factors” in judging the procedure (Choice Escrow) [5].
A federal court in Florida, quoting the official comment to the uniform law, added: “The standard is not whether the security procedure is the best available.” It found a username, password and token code reasonable (Harborview Realty v. Fifth Third Bank, M.D. Fla. 2024) [7].
Customers do win on strong facts. In one First Circuit case, the bank’s own system scored the fraudulent transfers far above the customer’s normal range, yet “no one at the bank monitored these high-risk transactions.” [8]
The court found the bank’s “collective failures, taken as a whole,” commercially unreasonable. It still suggested the parties “consider whether it would be wiser to invest their resources in resolving this matter by agreement” (Patco Construction v. People’s United Bank, 1st Cir. 2012) [8].
A missed warning is not bad faith
Good faith means “honesty in fact and the observance of reasonable commercial standards of fair dealing” (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-105) [9]. The bank’s honesty is rarely in question.
The fight is over fair dealing, which is not the same as care. As one court explained, it “is concerned with the fairness of conduct rather than the care with which an act is performed” (Experi-Metal v. Comerica Bank, E.D. Mich. 2011) [10].
So the fact that a bank’s systems overlooked suspicious activity does not, by itself, defeat good faith. In Harborview, thirteen payments were approved after the bank’s system flagged the first one.
The customer argued the bank should have investigated every high-risk score. The court called that “nothing more than Monday morning quarterbacking” and pointed to the agreement, which said the bank had “no obligation to use or comply with” its additional monitoring programs [7].
A contest of experts
What “reasonable commercial standards” require is usually shown through expert witnesses. The bank will describe each system it has in place, from authentication to alert review, and call an expert to say all of it met industry practice.
In Harborview, the bank’s expert was “uncontroverted,” the customer offered no expert in response, and the bank won without a trial [7].
In Experi-Metal, a criminal sent ninety-three wires totaling more than $1.9 million in about six and a half hours from a company with two prior wires. The bank lost, but largely because the court found its expert “not qualified” on online wire fraud, leaving the bank with no evidence of the applicable standards [10].
The outcome followed the evidence, not how alarming the transfers looked in hindsight.
Other claims and deadlines
Negligence rarely offers a second route. The Second Circuit has held that Article 4-A “preempted any common law claims inconsistent with its provisions” (Fischer & Mandell v. Citibank, 2d Cir. 2011) [11].
A customer also loses the right to object unless it notifies the bank “within one year” after receiving notice of the order (N.Y. UCC § 4-A-505) [12].
What a board should take from this
A claim against the bank is not a slam dunk. It can succeed, as Experi-Metal and Patco show, but it depends on documents and testimony the company does not yet have.
Before pursuing one, a board should ask for four things:
- The agreements. Every account and treasury agreement, including any arbitration, security-procedure, indemnity and fee clauses.
- The bank’s records. A written request that the bank preserve its logs, alerts and risk scores.
- A written objection. Notice to the bank disputing each transfer.
- An expert view. An early assessment from a qualified banking-security expert.
How Dilendorf Law Firm helps
Dilendorf Law Firm represents clients in wire fraud cases. We begin by investigating the facts of each transfer and how the account was accessed.
We consult with expert witnesses who are retired law enforcement agents to assess the strength of each case.
We also review the bank’s terms and conditions to determine the client’s exposure if the case is lost, including any clause that shifts the bank’s legal fees to the customer.
If you are a victim of wire fraud or a bank account takeover, please contact us for a consultation.
Sources
[1] N.Y. Uniform Commercial Code § 4-A-204, Refund of Payment and Duty of Customer to Report With Respect to Unauthorized Payment Order, New York State Senate. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/UCC/4-A-204
[2] N.Y. Uniform Commercial Code § 4-A-202, Authorized and Verified Payment Orders, New York State Senate. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/UCC/4-A-202
[3] 9 U.S.C. § 2, Validity, irrevocability, and enforcement of agreements to arbitrate, Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives. https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?edition=2023&num=0&req=granuleid:USC-2023-title9-section2
[4] N.Y. Uniform Commercial Code § 4-A-201, Security Procedure, New York State Senate. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/UCC/4-A-201
[5] Choice Escrow and Land Title, LLC v. BancorpSouth Bank, Nos. 13-1879 and 13-1931 (8th Cir. June 11, 2014), U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit. https://ecf.ca8.uscourts.gov/opndir/14/06/131879P.pdf
[6] N.Y. Uniform Commercial Code § 4-A-203, Unenforceability of Certain Verified Payment Orders, New York State Senate. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/UCC/4-A-203
[7] Harborview Realty, Inc. v. Fifth Third Bank, National Association, No. 2:21-cv-942 (M.D. Fla. July 18, 2024), U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida. https://ecf.flmd.uscourts.gov/cgi-bin/show_public_doc?2021-00942-92-2-cv
[8] Patco Construction Company, Inc. v. People’s United Bank, No. 11-2031 (1st Cir. July 3, 2012), U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. https://media.ca1.uscourts.gov/pdf.opinions/11-2031P-01A.pdf
[9] N.Y. Uniform Commercial Code § 4-A-105, Other Definitions, New York State Senate. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/UCC/4-A-105
[10] Experi-Metal, Inc. v. Comerica Bank, No. 09-14890 (E.D. Mich. June 13, 2011), GovInfo, U.S. Government Publishing Office. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-mied-2_09-cv-14890/pdf/USCOURTS-mied-2_09-cv-14890-3.pdf
[11] Fischer & Mandell LLP v. Citibank, N.A., No. 10-2155-cv (2d Cir. Feb. 3, 2011), GovInfo, U.S. Government Publishing Office. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca2-10-02155/pdf/USCOURTS-ca2-10-02155-0.pdf
[12] N.Y. Uniform Commercial Code § 4-A-505, Preclusion of Objection to Debit of Customer’s Account, New York State Senate. https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/UCC/4-A-505
This article is general information, not legal advice. The cases cited from outside New York apply other states’ versions of the same uniform law. Attorney Advertising.

