Why Germans Should Invest in U.S. Real Estate, But Not Through an LLC
Between April 2016 and March 2017, foreign buyers purchased a record $153 billion in residential real estate in the United States. Buyers from Germany were one of the top 10 groups of foreign buyers during that time. These investors were attracted to U.S. real estate for many reasons, but one that merits closer consideration is the favorable tax treatment available.
Under an income-tax treaty with the United States, Germany provides a tax exemption to its residents for income earned from U.S. real estate. That exemption enables German residents to earn U.S.-source income that is subject to tax only in the United States. U.S. taxation features several advantages over German taxes:
- Lower taxes on gain from the sale of real property. If an investor sells real property in the U.S. after owning it for more than one year, any gain would be taxed at a maximum rate of 20%. In Germany, the gain would be taxed at ordinary rates (up to 45%) unless the property was held for more than 10 years, in which case it would not be taxed.
- Lower taxes on rental income. The highest marginal rate in the U.S. is 37%; in Germany, it is 45%.
- Deferred gain. Investors in U.S. real estate can avoid recognizing gain when exchanging one property for another of like kind.
This article discusses these advantages in more detail, and offers a word of caution regarding the legal structure for Germans’ investments in U.S. real estate. Specifically, because of differences in how the U.S. and Germany treat U.S. limited liability companies (LLCs), Germans should avoid them. In their place, Germans should consider establishing a U.S. limited partnership.
The U.S.-Germany Income-Tax Treaty
The United States taxes the worldwide income of its citizens and residents, but only the U.S.-source income of nonresidents who are not citizens. Similarly, Germany taxes the worldwide income of its residents, but only the German-source income of nonresidents. These overlapping worldwide-tax regimes pose a risk that the same income will be taxed twice.
Example: Ben is a German resident who is not a U.S. citizen. He owns rental real estate in the United States. The income Ben earns from his U.S. real estate could be subject to tax twice:
- The U.S. could tax the rental income because it comes from a U.S. source.
- Germany could tax the rental income because Peter is a resident of Germany.
To alleviate the burden that such double taxation would impose, the United States and Germany entered an income-tax treaty in 1989. Under the treaty, only the U.S. may tax income from U.S. real estate. Germany does not tax the U.S.-source income, but does take it into account when determining the tax rate that applies to German-source income.
Three Advantages of U.S. Taxation for Germans
Thanks to the U.S.-Germany treaty, German investors can directly compare U.S. taxes and German taxes when considering whether to invest in real estate in one of the two countries. When they do, they will discover the following three advantages offered by U.S. real estate:
1. Lower Taxes Upon Sale
Long-term capital gains (LTCG) in the United States are taxed at reduced rates compared with ordinary income. LTCG are gains from the sale of capital assets, such as real estate, held for more than one year. The top rate on LTCG is 20%.
In contrast, capital gains in Germany are taxed at ordinary rates of up to 45%. Only if real estate has been held for more than 10 years will it receive favorable treatment—namely, the gain upon sale will be completely exempt from tax.
2. Lower Taxes on Rental Income
In general, U.S. taxes are lower than taxes in Germany. This is so for two reasons:
- Lower tax rates. In the United States, the highest federal marginal tax rate is 37%. In Germany, the highest marginal tax rate is 45%, and a further 5.5% solidarity tax is imposed on the amount of income tax paid.
- Lower tax base. A German will usually have less taxable income in the United States than in Germany. Because both countries use a system of progressive taxation, that means a German is less likely to pay at the highest marginal rate in the U.S. than in Germany.
3. Deferred Gain in a 1031 Exchange
Another advantage of U.S. real estate is the ability to defer gain through what is known as a 1031 exchange. Typically, upon the sale of real property in the United States, the seller must pay tax on the gain realized—the difference between what the property sells for and its original purchase price (as reduced by depreciation).
However, section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code allows taxpayers to defer recognizing such gain using a like-kind exchange. In a like-kind exchange, the seller reinvests the proceeds from the sale into property of “like kind”—e.g., real estate for real estate. As a result, the seller will not pay income tax on his or her gain until he or she later resells the newly acquired property.
Caution: Germans Should Avoid LLCs for Their U.S. Investments
Although investing in U.S. real estate offers these advantages for German residents, it also poses some traps for the unwary. For many American investors and others around the world, U.S. limited liability companies (LLCs) are the preferred legal structure for their U.S. holdings.
However, Germans should generally avoid LLCs, because Germany may treat the LLC differently for tax purposes than the U.S. does, causing the LLC’s income to be taxed twice.
U.S. and German tax laws both permit an LLC to be treated as an “opaque” entity—one that pays its own taxes, like a corporation—or as a “transparent” entity—one in which the owners pay tax on the entity’s income, as in a partnership.
In the United States, the owners of an LLC can choose which tax treatment will apply to the LLC. But in Germany, the government determines how to classify an LLC based on whether the LLC is more like a corporation or a partnership under German law.
If an LLC is treated as a transparent entity in the United States, but as an opaque entity in Germany, then the LLC’s income will be subject to double taxation—once in the United States when the income is earned, and once in Germany when the LLC distributes money to its owners.
Because of this risk, Germans investing in U.S. real estate should instead use a limited partnership, which both Germany and the United States tax as a transparent entity.
Germans remain one of the largest groups of foreign investors buying U.S. real estate. They do so for many reasons, not least of which are the tax advantages offered by the U.S.-Germany income-tax treaty and domestic U.S. tax law. However, German investors must be careful when investing in U.S. real estate to ensure that the holding structure they choose is appropriate for their investment and tax goals.
Tax Disclaimer: The information contained herein is general in nature and based on authorities that are subject to change. We do not guarantee neither the accuracy nor completeness of any information and is not responsible for any errors or omissions, or for results obtained by others as a result of reliance upon such information. We assume no obligation to inform the reader of any changes in tax laws or other factors that could affect information contained herein. This publication does not, and is not intended to, provide legal, tax or accounting advice, and readers should consult their tax advisors concerning the application of tax laws to their particular situations.
Other ResourcesALL ARTICLES
Max Dilendorf, Esq.
Max Dilendorf’s practice is focused primarily on digital assets, cryptocurrency, and technologies that drive blockchain and related distributive computing networks. An early adopter of virtual currency and associated legal, financial, and business implications, Max is considered the go-to expert for anything ...Learn More
Bari Zahn, Esq.
Bari Zahn has nearly 20 years of experience practicing at global law firms in New York. Bari has represented a broad array of multinational clients on U.S. and cross-border transactions. She has supervised legal teams worldwide and has extensive management experience as the Founder, former CEO and General ...Learn More
Adam is one of the nation’s leading young whistleblower lawyers. He brings with him a special ability not just to litigate, but to investigate – and understand – complex organizations and transactions. His extensive familiarity with tech issues is built on a computer science degree and work as a ...Learn More
Steve contributes extensive business and problem-solving experience to challenges that may require litigation – or may help avoid it. Indeed, his perspective on litigation is influenced by his experience as a three-time internet start-up CEO.
Steve served on Ronald Reagan’s 1980 presidential campaign ...Learn More
Pamela A. Fuller, Esq.
Pamela A. Fuller is a corporate and international tax attorney, with over two decades of experience. She advises a wide range of clients–including private and public companies, joint ventures, private equity and hedge funds, C-Suite executives, private U.S and foreign individual clients, and government ...Learn More
Ivanna has 7 years of law practice in Europe, namely in the field of corporate law, M&A transactions, banking and finance. As a senior associate, she advised local, EU, US and multinational clients with respect to their business activities in Ukraine.
Particularly, Ivanna, together with junior associates ...Learn More